site-logo
  • HOME
  • SERVICES
    • Conversion Rate Optimization
    • Web Development
    • E-commerce development
    • How We Work
  • PORTFOLIO
    • Development Work
    • Landing Pages
  • ABOUT US
  • OUR BLOG
  • CONTACT
Get in touch
  • All Categories
  • Conversion
  • CRO
  • Team
  • Usability
  • User Centered Design
  • User Research

Should We Drop Demographics in Favour of Behaviour or Personality Types?

November 5, 2022 | All Categories, User Research  | Author: Daniel Chabert

When selecting participants for customer research projects or evaluating and categorising their responses, there are a number of questions that arise. Should you select and group participants based on the age or gender of your target audience? Or perhaps based on their previous purchases or contact? Or even based on their character traits? There is a wide range of factors that need to be considered and we’ll address a few of these in this post, highlighting the strength and weakness of each approach.

Successful selection and grouping of participants is founded on having a segmented view of your audience. Going back to basics, segmentation is key to getting the best value out of customer research and making sure that marketing efforts reach the right people. Careful planning upfront can save you money and improve ROI’s.

Table of contents:

  • 1 Demographics
  • 2 Behaviour
  • 3 Personality
  • 4 Conclusion:

Demographics

Selecting and grouping participants based on demographics (e.g. gender, race, age, location) is often the most straightforward approach. It has some very obvious applications, for example, a women’s clothing brand will get more useful insight using female participants. Age can also be useful if your customers are clearly defined or perhaps if you were looking to target a new, younger or older audience. Age tends to impact a range of factors such as disposable income available, taste, amount of time available, etc. However, we find that the importance of is often overplayed and participants do not fit into the neat stereotypes that we anticipate. For example, when we found recently that some teens had greater than expected spending power because their parents were willing to make the payments. In summary, demographics can be a great starting place and can filter out less useful participants, but as we’ll see. Stop here and you’re missing a trick.

We also find that it really depends on your research objectives as to how specific your participants need to match you target audience. For matters of persuasion and taste, it tends to be important, but if you are looking to test the usability and intuitiveness of your website, using participants outside of your target audience might not be a bad thing. For example, using a less technically savvy profile (e.g. 60+, beginner or mid-level web users) may highlight areas of your user experience that are unclear and could be improved.

Pros:

  • Quickly filter out participants that are wildly different to your target audience.
  • If you have a change in strategy and want to target a new audience. For example, a younger or older audience, or when adding a new line of products for men/women if they are not your traditional audience.

Cons:

  • If the demographic restrictions are too strict, then you can filter out a lot of participants who might provide useful insight. This can make it difficult to recruit the required number of participants.
  • Easy to filter out useful participants who fall just outside often slightly arbitrary age ranges.

Behaviour

Another way to select and group participants is to find an activity or form of behaviour that makes them more relevant. Previous online experiences may be valuable, for example, you may want to only select visitors who are new to the website to get their first impressions and observe them learning how to use the site. Alternatively, after a new release or set of changes, it might be helpful to get the views of returning customers or power users who understand the proposition clearly and can give an educated verdict on the changes or mention any remaining bugbears.

It is also worth considering offline behaviour. A sports retailer may want to attract competitive athletes and could therefore include a qualifying question such as:

I train at least 4 times a week and compete at national championships. Yes/No.

This allows you to be more specific about the type of participant that you select and will provide evidence to build depth into your marketing segments.

As well as setting narrow fields like the example above, you could also use a qualifying question to filter out negative behaviours, for example:

I have shopped, or would consider shopping online. Yes/No

Pros:

  • Allows you to select more tightly focused, highly relevant participants
  • Can filter out less relevant participants
  • Can help to include demographic information in web personas to bring them to life and make them more believable.

Cons:

  • Depending on your recruitment method, qualifying questions may increase the cost of recruitment.
  • If the qualifying question is too specific, it may be challenging to recruit the required number of testers and they may need to be relaxed.

Personality

One of the challenging factors that the previous two methods don’t accurately account for is less concrete characteristics, such as a participant’s personality. Do they want every possible detail or simply to be delighted by an exciting experience? Will they respond best a personable experience with social proof or are they more task driven, looking for simplicity and efficiency? What drives their buying decisions and what journey or content will improve the experience for them? These factors will vary greatly amongst website users and types of website. A

Developing a set of web personas and using these to guide your participant selection and future marketing efforts can be a great way of refining your target audiences beyond simple stereotypes.

Pros:

  • Allows you to be more specific in grouping users and
  • Helps you understand user’s decision-making processes

Cons:

  • Can be difficult to recruit based on personality

Conclusion:

The reality is that in order to get the most out of customer research, it’s best to be equipped with a full toolkit of demographic, behavioural and personality based filters. Whether optimizing an existing website, redesigning or planning new marketing campaigns carefully constructed segments, research participants and web personas are a really powerful tool. In most cases a mixture of all three approaches may be applicable and if you have always selected participants and group the findings by demographic filters, we strongly recommend investigating whether behavioural and personality based approaches could improve your website and campaigns.

If you have any relevant experiences please share them in the comments. Thanks!

Daniel Chabert
Daniel Chabert is a leading expert on Conversion Rate Optimization. He has worked in the industry for 10 years. He has sold 3 eCommerce businesses for 7 figures combined. Today he is the CEO at PurpleFire.
Our 3 Recent Videos

  • Convert.com - How to start A/B testing on your Website (Webinar)

    Convert.com - How to start A/B testing on your Website (Webinar)

  • Jones Road Beauty - Let's do a Full Customer Journey Redesign in Shopify

    Jones Road Beauty - Let's do a Full Customer Journey Redesign in Shopify

  • Warby Parker - E-commerce Brand - Before/After case study - Conversion Rate Optimization

    Warby Parker - E-commerce Brand - Before/After case study - Conversion Rate Optimization

Contact us
CRO specialist
Let's discuss how we can boost your sales via CRO

Recently posted

How to Use Surveys to Boost Your Conversion Rate

[embed]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dPM8IMvuxo&t=1s[/embed] Surveys are an underrated tool for boosting your conversion rate. In this article, we’ll show you how to set up surveys, what software to use, and...
Read More

10 Best A/B Split-Testing Software Compared in 2023

If you’re a conversion rate optimization marketer or just a marketer looking to expand your repertoire, you need the best tools in the market. Split testing proves your experiment ...
Read More

The Art of Persuasion: Psychology Principles and Optimisation

Seeing how psychological principles can influence website visitors in various ways is one aspect of website optimization that I find most fascinating. Within the industry, ‘persuasion’ could be seen as something of a ...
Read More

Contact us

Drop us a line and we will get back to you asap to discuss your awesome idea or provide answers to your technical questions.
Get in touch
  • Home
  • About Us
  • How we develop
  • Contact
  • Web Development
  • Blog
49 reviews
image
Copyright © 2023 PurpleFire - All rights reserved.